WORK LIFE / BALANCE DEBATE - Part I: A BUSINESS, A HR, OR PERSONAL CHOICE?

-
Work/Life balance exists and is possible for privileged functions. It is undeniably  accessible at both ends of the spectrum: high- and low-end positions, and globally, to a certain extent. The difference is in income stability and real choices. Is work/life balance just empty words or an intellectual speech for some of us? In a SHRM article, it is defined as a myth. So true, it is a matter of priorities.
ACC Report- 2014 (on In-House Counsels)



TOUCH: THREE ASPECTS OF WORK/LIFE BALANCE

 

Until you know first hand through one way or another about a specific subject, it is just talk, intellectualized talk. If you have ever been in a French environment, you would know about dwelling into that intellectual talk. Somehow inexplicably satisfying.  So, flexibility, let's talk about it, really: you have to touch and feel it. Then you would be able to say that you know it, from an individual standpoint. There are three major faces of Work/Life Balance.

1- Work/Life Balance by Occupation


At one end of the spectrum is the face of life/work balance that is in essence available  to economically- or financially- privileged occupations. Many children of medical professionals have chosen to avoid the field because they feel that their parent(s) are too absent or too unavailable. The same goes for children of many business executives. By the same token, many professionals prefer to stay at the middle or lower management levels, by choice of lifestyle. But that's because those children or individuals only saw one aspect of the profession(s). In fact, some occupations offer life/work balance, in essence. You may choose your "life" availability by electing your profession in the first place. You still have the ability to balance your lifestyle and your work requirements by choosing your occupation. An emergency physician will be assigned, and should be prepared to honor, emergency hours; it will not be the same for a cosmetic surgeon, as simplistic examples. Somehow, you would have made the primary choice by choosing your field of action. Life/Work balance is in the eye of the beholder. Somehow, it can be pre-elected. At the other end of the spectrum is work/life balance by necessity.

 2- Work/life balance by Necessity

 

According to a Time magazine recent study and 2014 data 70 percent of workers "suffer from work-family tension." Yet, according to a Glassdoor study 25 companies have the best work/life balance policies.  Employees are happy. Is it a matter of profession, company, or sector?
If work/Life balance can be a matter of life choice to some, it is an imposed necessity to others. This article from Money Watch gives us so many examples of workers having to choose between their own livelihood and "flexibility" aka "work/life balance". It is presented as flexibility, yet, it translates into loss of income, increased instability, and/or loss of work, or even major sacrifices to workers. Yet, businesses and HR promote and advertise life/work balance, through telecommuting, flexibility and .com functions. It is now one of the major selling points of organizations to candidates. A "scheme" says Eikhof, "myopic" policies reinforces  Warhurst. This is the face of work/life balance by necessity.


 3- Work/life balance by "Claim"

 

Thirdly, there is work/life balance by claim. The claim that "women can have it all" is a matter of intellectual debate. No later than last week, this mother opted for a part-time position because she wanted to be more available for her daughter. Is that having it all? It is not exclusively a matter of gender, either.  More egalitarian societies have men encountering more issues with work/life balance.
With new technologies, work might have become easier but also more personally intrusive.
So here is the deal: Workers may claim that they have found work/life balance because they can juggle family and work in a happy fashion, in their fashion; and HR may claim that they have achieved the best work/life balance policies through teleworking and flexibility.

OPEN DEBATE

So, work/life balance policies are open to debate. The intellectual argument is about its volatility and superficiality. The practical debate is about its usefulness as an answer to the question "does flexibility really exist when one has to choose between working at more accommodating times or hours and losing income?" The business debate is: how can we engage workers and make them embrace the policies that we are compelled to design in order to optimize our compensation costs and gain a competitive advantage?

En Synthèse

Le débat life/work balance: rêve, réalité, nécessité, ou paradis? Comment rester zen?


En Synthèse


Tout un débat, n'est-ce pas? J'aime pour synthétiser les choses citer ce tout dernier edito de mes bonnes copines: rafraîchissant. Alors, life/work balance ou conciliation travail/famille pas seulement un rêve mais un paradis?

N'est ce qu'un mythe? En tous les cas, une réalité personnelle ou devrais-je dire personnalisée. Tout est justifiable, que ce soit de la part des individus ou des organisations. La flexibilité, la technologie, tant que cela n’empiète pas trop sur la vie et la survie des gens, oui. En tous cas, les conditions de travail et réglementations sur la flexibilité sont très différentes en France par comparaison aux  USA. En tous cas, tout dépend des pays.  Mais est-ce tout? Entrent en jeu le secteur d’activités et le genre de travail.

Moi, je définis la conciliation travail/famille sous trois aspects:
1- Par Profession: l'on choisit une profession et un poste avec les conséquences. Décision informée.
2 - Par Nécessité: l'on accepte les conditions imposées de flexibilité car l'on doit nourrir sa famille
3 - Par Forte Présomption Personnelle: l'on se dit que cela marche pour soi.
Car après tout, c'est une question de choix, que l'on le veuille ou non, que l'on y croie ou pas.  Quant aux entreprises, elles doivent faire marcher la roue, coûte que coûte.  Les RH sont plus "humains" dans certains pays que dans d'autres. A bon entendeur, salut!


Et pour la petite histoire du grand débat sur le sujet (ou un autre! :) ), et pour rendre à César ce qui est à César, je voudrais partager cet article destiné aux Américains qui est aussi proche de la réalité que jamais lu ni entendu autour de moi! Kudos à Dr. Guy Spielmann!







Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

COMMUNICATION, SAFETY & WORKPLACE: "Je suis Charlie"

-
Image
©AR_HRComatrix_SCharlie C ommunication is powerful, today more than ever, with social media . Frontiers are erased . Time elapses. Things and situations take a different dimension. Everything is "here and now ". This week, " Je suis Charlie " has been the most recent and poignant picture of the power of communication. All started and ended in the workplace . Chilling for HR and Safety people. P eople all the over the world spend most of their time at work . The typical workday is about six to eight hours in the the US with the new approach to the notion of full time job . In France it is typically eight hours, with often some flexibility, and despite the official 35 hours a week. . How can we protect workers against unexpected violence since they spend most of their time at work? H R is not about damage control ; it is about proactivity . Disturbingly enough, only 31% of workplaces in the US seem to be proactive in emergency preparedness, acco...
Read more

CATCHING FIRE: WORDS of WISDOM ABOUT and FROM MILLENNIALS- LESSONS FROM MILLENNIALS Part II -

-
Image
A lot has been said about Millennials. There are you tube videos , articles , blogs , research and polls... Most of them trying to help us understand this new generation. They appear as aggressive, daring, intimidating,  careless, smart, fast, clueless, in sum "different," regardless on who sees them. They certainly have many faces. Turning a New Leaf With Millennials © 2013 AR_HRCom-Millennials Those of us who have been working side by side with them have most likely experienced mixed feelings. It is basically turning a new leaf. Let's move toward greener fields! These young  partners can be exuberant and very lively and their concerns about professional or personal life can feel overwhelming. Often times you get what you see and hear. Does it make your assessment easier? I doubt. To me the challenge in assessment comes from the necessity to distance oneself from the individual. The ability to intellectualize things in this matter is a real gift. I can dea...
Read more

Holistic HR - Part I: Is Mental Wellness Relevant?

-
Image
Ad_HRComtx_1_620 © A s we are navigating the new ways of work, one aftermath of the pandemic for many of us is the unpleasant discovery of unvisited or neglected matters: our mental wellness. More than ever HR has to embrace its evolving approach to its core responsibility: HR is about "the whole person". T he pandemic has brought to the surface so many elements that neither HR nor the people had thought about, although always existing. To me, the two major concerns about mental wellness are depression and domestic violence. I have to admit that I never seriously thought about it until I lost sleep myself and couldn't understand why I was so inexplicably restless and unfocused. Quite a few people I talked to shared similar occurrences. This can only be exacerbated by the sense of isolation from familiar working environment as we work from home or are still transitioning to go back to work. If any of this happened to you, you are quite normal in highly abnormal ti...
Read more

Holistic HR - Part II: Socially Distant and Staying Relevant

-
Image
Ted_HRComtx_HolisticHR © Carving a Path for 2021 I t is said that silence is death, and that no news is good news. I have to say that I have been like many of us: affected in one way of another by Covid, being socially distant within relevancy. New resolutions? At least, carving a new path... in this icy cold world full of hot topics. It is not easy: it takes daring and willingness.   T he new year - already not feeling so new by now - has to be better in many ways, because it is practically a call to duty. What the pandemic has brought to us is not isolation but the exposure to a global environment that could reveal itself to be highly toxic , as well as the possibility of exacerbation of some situations of at-risk people . As we advance into 2021 we see the emergence of Wellbeing vs. Wellness verbiage because if anything last year has brought to light, it is the awareness of the importance of mental health .  This is more than ever a reason to understand and embrace that...
Read more

WORK LIFE / BALANCE DEBATE- PART II: The Five TOPS by Regions, Countries, Companies and Jobs -

-
Image
The FIVE MOST IMPORTANT ISSUES BY REGIONS and COUNTRIES I t is educating to see the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)  map of better life index . The assessment of better life varies by regions and by countries, from life satisfaction to safety through education and environment. OECD better life index responses - 2014 Interesting enough, Health is primary in France, Canada, Australia, the Russian Federation,  and Norway. Life-Work balance is important in Mauritius Island, Mali, Montenegro and Nicaragua. Life Satisfaction prevails in US, Germany, UK, as well as Croatia, Poland and Sweden and Finland. Safety is paramount in Japan, Venezuela, Kazakhstan, and The Bahamas. Education is important in Mexico, Brazil, Chile and Argentina The FIVE TOP COMPANIES According to Glassdoor, there are 25 companies that are rated to be the best in work/life balance policies. Employees do love it. Those organizations include non-profit, as w...
Read more

Christmas ..Holidays...Party Season..Why?

-
Image
You Party because You are Expected To .... By now you have your Holiday party planned or maybe you are already over it. Preparation can be hectic . You have been trying to give another nice end-of-year party and your hopes are that it will be. It is amazing when we break it into pieces how many things something as simple and as common as a end-of-year Holiday party could involve. From very small to very large organizations, the idea behind it is to cultivate good employee relations . Employees look forward to this event. Life partners are involved in "shopping" for the occasion. It is indeed the networking event of the year for many, the one coming after social networking . As a child I remember going to business Christmas parties where the whole family was invited and children given very nice presents by Santa Claus! For HR, it falls into a busy period: time for performance reviews, time for seasonal hiring for some, time for reporting, and this year, time for prepar...
Read more